"SYTYCD" Season 16 Recap: And Then There Were Six
Eight dancers survived the first cuts last week. By the end of this episode, six remain. But first: two hours, two duets each, two group routines, and eight solos. Here’s what went down.
The Opening Number
Make some noise for your biggest night of dance yet! 📣👏🌈 #SYTYCD https://t.co/XDHOq4EDPF
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566866011.0
Oh this was fun and fancy! The Top 8 stepped out onstage in flashy feathers, fringe, neon, high heels, and higher ponytails. There were backflips. There were huge lifts. There were leaps, jumps, tricks, turns. There were glow sticks in the audience! So yeah, there was a lot, courtesy of choreographers Jonathan and Oksana Platero. Power to these eight dancers for keeping their energy up throughout what felt like a very long opening number! (Who caught your eye the most? Madison and Mariah were the scene stealers for us.) Welcome! To “So You Think You Can Dance!”
Anna & Benjamin, Tahitian with Tiana Liufau
Ride the wave of @annvchristine and @benjycastro01’s routine! 🌊 #SYTYCD https://t.co/t8L7NmSBwW
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566866290.0
First, how about a shout-out to “SYT” for really going above and beyond over the past 16 seasons to bring worldly dance forms to the small screen. Without this show, would mainstream audiences in the U.S. know about African Jazz, Tahitian, or Bollywood? As for this one, we’re just going to say it: Benjamin totally out-danced Anna. He was lower, groovier, more hyped, just more. Anna looked lovely, but she was sweet and smiley where Benjamin was living. It just didn’t feel like a balanced performance. Nigel said it didn’t sit comfortably with him, Mary said something about calling the dance police (translation: she loved it), Dominic said their hips told him a great story, and Laurieann said a lot of stuff all indicating she was in favor of the performance. (Soooo none of the judges agreed with our assessment. All good!)
🔥 + ❤️+ 🧠 = @PittmanSophie’s sweet solo! #SYTYCD https://t.co/zK9LRnNBzK
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566866932.0
Yay, solos, finally! A chance to see these dancers shine in their own styles and really go for it. Sophie’s contemporary solo was sweet and stylized, with lots of quick spins. Stunning!
Madison & Ezra, Hip Hop with Randi and Hef
🚀 @madisonrosejord and @ezra_sosa are explorin’ the universe! #SYTYCD https://t.co/QzHFaZ1B56
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566867187.0
Fly me to the moon—but make it hip hop. Madison and Ezra were dancing astronauts in this piece, complete with spacesuits and a very cool descent down to the stage. Both of these dancers are fantastic, and they consistency excel at hitting every single beat in whatever choreography they’re given. This was no exception. They were on point. But! Madison was super smiley, which seemed a bit out of place at times. Her dancing was so good! But a little too smiley! Mary was feeling some of it, but not all. Dominic noted that Madison is an awesome hip-hop dancer, and said she stood out for him. Laurieann dubbed it “out of this world.” (Someone had to go there!) And Nigel said it was generally brilliant.
🔥 @gino_t13 is burnin’ up the stage! #SYTYCD https://t.co/cSiX4N2pZy
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566867744.0
An Andra Day Hamilton cover (“Burn,” specifically) and no fewer than 824 tricks in 30 seconds. Bravo, Gino. (Is anyone else really wishing Maddie Ziegler were a judge this season? #firstkiss #neverforget. But she was in the audience, so that’s fun!)
Mariah & Bailey, Cha Cha with Dmitry Chaplin
Nous aimons cette danse! 💃🕺@MariahRussell_ @bailrok #SYTYCD https://t.co/eYEJKWyG9e
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566868041.0
These two have been dubbed the team to beat which, Mariah notes during rehearsal, adds a good amount of pressure. So why not throw them a challenging Cha Cha with a former “SYT” star to really see if they can stay on top? The rehearsal footage indicated that these two would be riding the struggle bus straight to elimination station. Instead, the pulled it OFF, trading a struggle bus for the Hot Tamale Train. Yes, Bailey is smaller than Mariah. Yes, he can still be a darn good partner and toss her around in some complicated lifts—and he proved it during this routine. These two are such dynamic performers and have so much chemistry. This wasn’t their best performance to date, but it was solid. Dominic said Bailey struggled on those lifts, but said that was adorable, and that he fell in love with these two even more after that performance. Laurieann called it a “big girl, big boy” routine. Nigel used the words “greatness” and “brilliant” And Mary was all “CHOO CHOO,” which means, yes of course, Hot Tamale time! (Also, Bailey gets Mariah flowers before every live show. Can we talk about that? LOVE THAT.)
We’re overwhelmed by the beauty of @madisonrosejord’s solo! 😍 #SYTYCD https://t.co/V92R5fZ4ax
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566868388.0
Madison consistently dances with fluidity, with grace, with passion. She’s a dynamic group performer and a strong partner, but it was a treat to see her do her own thing for 30 quick seconds. It wasn’t anything particularly memorable, but 60-second solos usually aren’t. This was strong and on par with everything we’ve grown to know, love, and expect from Madison.
Travel to Miami with @ezra_sosa! 🌴☀️ #SYTYCD https://t.co/AlteR4UxlQ
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566868434.0
Conga! A bright red vest with matching pants and shoes! A shaking booty! Ezra is awesome, and this performance was fun and fabulous.
Sophie & Gino, Contemporary with KC Monnie
See the whole picture… @PittmanSophie @gino_t13 #SYTYCD https://t.co/Fp1MffNpQX
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566868974.0
A new partnership! And wow. In this piece, Gino was telling new-to-“SYT” choreographer KC Monnie’s story about coming out to his loved ones. And wow. Wow wow wow. This was really powerful and emotional, and the fact that it was set to “You Will Be Found” from Dear Evan Hansen almost felt cruel. Cue the waterworks, amirite? Sophie and Gino danced beautifully together. Their chemistry was immediate. This was just lovely. Laurieann called this pairing magical. (Agreed.) Nigel said their chemistry is magnificent. (Agreed.) Mary, through tears, said this routine will be remembered all season, and Dominic thanked Sophie and Gino for this performance.
👏 @MariahRussell_ is that somebody! #SYTYCD https://t.co/htYCCzyC1Q
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566869300.0
I want to be Mariah when I grow up. She used her half a minute to perform with life, passion, and purpose—as she always does.
Anna & Benjamin, Broadway with Al Blackstone
✨ @annvchristine and @benjycastro01 brought the magic. ✨ #SYTYCD https://t.co/JIQLETS1ae
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566869592.0
Did anyone else get The Notebook vibes from this performance? It was slow and sweet, with all the signature, stylized elements that make a piece distinctively Broadway, but without the flash, the jazz, the sparkles, the spotlights. It felt almost indulgent to linger in the moments of stillness, of quiet, of calm. Nigel called it gentle and beautiful, but said it wasn’t what people are likely to vote for. Mary said it was played just right, with just the right amount of magic. Dominic used the word genius! And Laurieann said, “THAT WAS AMAZING.” All caps implied.
Madison & Ezra, Argentine Tango with Leonardo and Miriam
It takes ✌️ to tango! @madisonrosejord @ezra_sosa #SYTYCD https://t.co/mqV1UEekyf
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566869937.0
This style is, historically, a potential death sentence on this show. (Fittingly, the choreographers explained, Ezra represents death in the piece.) Ezra, of course, is a bona fide ballroom babe. But, he admitted during rehearsals, this style is one in which he has zero training. And yet, they pulled it off. These two really do dance well together. They’re so strong individually, that when it comes time to move in unison, it seems almost…easy? Nothing about this show is easy, but these two make it look that way every week. (Quick question: Can Madison get an Emmy for Best High-Kicking Legs? Holy cow.) Best Argentine Tango ever on “SYT?” No. It wasn’t particularly remarkable or memorable, but it was good. And that last lift was excellent. Mary noted how difficult the choreography was, with all the complicated combinations, lifts, and tricks—and said they did it all beautifully. Dominic gave Ezra some love, which was nice to hear. Laurieann called it intense and cinematic, and Nigel said it was well done.
Run, @benjycastro01, run! 🏃♂️ #SYTYCD https://t.co/cnsIEGBnvo
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566870107.0
Shirtless with a skirt and slicked-back hair. You win, Benjamin, All the solos were good, but Benjamin really went for it. This was so energetic, so explosive, so much. It was the only solo of the night we were begging not to end!
🤯 @annvchristine is blowin’ our minds! #SYTYCD https://t.co/CqfuuK6Ff4
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566870308.0
Does anyone else keep forgetting that Anna is a hip hopper? Every week, she has proved that she can do other styles really, really well. This solo was a nice, if somewhat tame, reminder that she’s an OG hip hopper.
Mariah & Bailey, Contemporary with Mandy and Elizabeth
In our feelings thanks to @MariahRussell_ and @bailrok. 😢 #SYTYCD https://t.co/jlVCoKtuWq
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566870600.0
“Being small, it’s hard to find love.” —Bailey, during rehearsals. Bailey! Could not possibly love this guy more. Meanwhile, Mariah said she was pumped to get to finally dance in her style. And OMG. These two. This piece. The rooftop prop was a lovely touch, and something the show, in its 16 seasons, has never seen. Mandy and Elizabeth really created something special here. And Bailey and Mariah danced it so beautifully, really giving into the choreography without letting the prop take over the routine. (This isn’t easy!) It was reminiscent of Katee and tWitch’s door routine. Remember? This was just really nice to watch. (And again, Bailey, crushing those lifts, proving HEIGHT AIN’T NO THANG!) Dominic said this was one of his favorite routines in all 16 seasons. (Wowowowow!) Laurieann called Bailey brilliant and said “Muffin” (Mariah) did well, too. Nigel said they are still the team to beat, and Mary told the world she wants Mariah and Bailey to be partners for the rest of their lives. NO PRESSURE, THOUGH.
Sophie & Gino, Jazz with Jonathan Redavid
In this piece, Gino and Sophie were tasked with, uh, being a new couple getting to know each other. Pretty fitting for the pair dancing together for the first week! And oh baby, was this a way to get to know each other! (I, personally, have never had a first date twirl me around quite like Gino twirled Sophie. Anyone else?) Sophie was sharp and sexy, and Gino was strong and swaggy. The first half was flirty, and the second half was high-energy. There was one lift that was a near-miss, but Gino salvaged it! Look, we were sad to say sayonara to Steph and Eddie, but it meant getting these two as partners, which is an absolute treat. What fun! Laurieann said it was soulful and called Sophie and Gino the new couple to beat. (!!!) Nigel agreed, saying Mariah and Bailey have “great opponents.” Mary gave them tickets to board the Hot Tamale Train, and Dominic said it was the best performance of the season for each of them.
Shut up and watch @bailrok dance! 🤫🕺 #SYTYCD https://t.co/ODsWlNL0yl
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566871117.0
OMG THE FUNNEST. Bailey for President. Bailey for everything. We said Benjamin’s solo was the best of the night so far, but then Bailey came out and did this. So…yeah. Tough call. Loved ’em both.
Contemporary Group Routine by Talia Favia
Madison, Mariah, Benjamin, and Gino, clad in black hoodies and dancing to Billie Eilish’s “Bad Guy,” came out ready to throw down. They were serious, but alluringly kind of sexy. Mysterious and angsty. And by the end, Gino and Benjamin were shirtless. Mary called it strong, powerful, and tough. All the judges loved it, and notably loved the shirtless part. Dominic talked a lot about the abs. Everyone laughed a lot. But yeah, unanimous praise and loads of giggles.
Pause for results!
After last week’s votes, Cat chimed in with an update: Gino was safe, meaning Benjamin was in danger. Mariah was also safe, putting Madison in danger of leaving. WE HATE THIS PART RIGHT HERE.
African Jazz Group Routine by Sean Cheesman
Experiencing a rebirth after that number by @annvchristine, @PittmanSophie, @bailrok and @ezra_sosa! ✨ #SYTYCD https://t.co/q7Tetf6L4V
— SYTYCD (@SYTYCD)1566871878.0
Sophie, Bailey, Anna, and Ezra’s group routine had a totally different vibe than the contemporary crew. It was primal and exciting. It started slow, then built to a high-energy explosion of tricks and really, really, really fast choreography. This looked exhausting. Mary was feeling it, Dominic thanked the dancers, Laurieann welcomed them to the dream, and Nigel…praised Bailey’s solo. Can’t blame him!
Ezra and Anna found themselves in danger. Sophie and Bailey were sent to safety.
Ultimately, the judges saved Madison and Ezra, which meant Anna and Benjamin were the next two voted off the island. And then there were six…