Costume Conundrum: When the Fit Isn’t “Just Right”
Slipping into your costume for the first time can feel magical. Whether tutu or leotard, Sugar Plum Fairy or contemporary solo, there’s a bubbling excitement that comes with dressing the part. But when the costume doesn’t fit—or any sort of discomfort arises—not knowing how to say so can put a young dancer in a tricky situation.
A spectrum of experiences can emerge around costume fit and discomfort. So what can we do in those uncomfortable positions, and how can you distinguish between distaste and a deeper issue?
The Range of Costume Problems
Not liking a costume is common among dancers. Some costumes may simply not be your style. Others may be scratchy or ill-colored. But those moments, while unfortunate, usually don’t cross the line of functionality. The larger concern arises when a dancer’s costume does not support them or makes them feel unsafe and insecure. “If you’re worried that your chest might fall out, that your costume is going to ride up and expose you, or that you can’t perform your choreography without constantly adjusting what you’re wearing, that’s a completely different issue [than dislike],” says Sophie Mckie, dance teacher and founder of art and advocacy brand Milibelle.
The same costume won’t fit every dancer the same way; while some people may need more support, others may need more coverage or alterations to better fit their proportions. Still others may not feel comfortable showing a certain amount of skin. “None of those things should be a big deal, and they certainly shouldn’t be made to feel like a problem,” says Mckie.
Fit Check
Many costume crises can be avoided by properly fitting dancers beforehand. According to Marissa McCullough, director of dance costumes at University of North Carolina School of the Arts, that’s why her department measures incoming dancers upon arrival.
McCullough encourages dancers to take a proactive, not reactive, approach that extends throughout the costume-creation phases. With tutus, UNCSA’s costumers add several rows of closures to the backs of the garments to make them adjustable and wearable across body types.
Mckie suggests that teachers and choreographers look at sizing options, as well as the costume’s cut, coverage, and support—and, with those considerations in mind—how it might restrict or facilitate movement. (That includes how comfortable and secure a dancer feels.) She adds that resources like body stockings, skin-tone shorts, supportive undergarments, or extra lining can make an “enormous difference” in the dancer’s experience.
Handing Back the Hand-Me-Downs
But at most studios, costumes are not custom; they’re passed down, so it’s common for dancers to pull on old costumes that aren’t designed for their specific body type. Depending on style and materials, stock costumes can leave little room for adjustment, especially for younger dancers whose bodies continue to grow and shift each year. (What fits in June may feel unsupportive or too tight by Nutcracker season.) In these situations, a dancer’s strongest tools are their voice and the community around them.
“The best thing you can do is advocate for yourself,” says McCullough. “From a costumer’s point of view, if I put something on you and ask how it feels and you say ‘good,’ I’m moving on to the next thing.”
Young dancers might find self-advocacy challenging, especially in environments where voicing concerns is not encouraged. That’s why Mckie stresses the importance of adults, guardians, and teachers stepping up first—and listening. “We shouldn’t be putting all the responsibility on children to advocate for themselves,” she says. “They’re still learning how to use their voices, and for some dancers, having to talk to an adult about their body can be incredibly confronting. We need to make sure that when they do find the courage to speak up, they’re actually listened to.” What worries her the most, she says, is the message it sends when adults “treat a dancer’s body as the inconvenience, rather than the costume that doesn’t fit them.”
Tailoring Your Approach
How you choose to raise the issue of an unsupportive garment is key to securing a successful outcome. Start by identifying the true problem, and be prepared to articulate it accurately. What about the costume makes you feel unsafe? What adjustments could be made to fix that?
“Explain exactly what is making you uncomfortable,” says Mckie. “Rather than just saying you don’t like the costume, tell your teacher what you’re worried about. Maybe it’s that you don’t feel supported when you jump, or you’re worried about how much coverage you have when you kick.” If you’re not comfortable having that conversation yourself, she says, ask a parent or another trusted adult to help. Remember that the adults you confide in should approach your issue or discomfort with serious care and not minimize the feelings you express.
Teachers and directors have an enormous amount of influence over how young dancers see themselves. “I’ve had conversations with adult dancers who can still remember comments made about their bodies when they were 8 or 9 years old,” says Mckie. “The way we respond in that moment can determine whether that dancer ever feels comfortable speaking up again.” That’s why it’s important for leaders to create safe spaces for addressing costume concerns, which includes proactively asking questions about fit and feel—not waiting for them to be brought up after the fact.
In Mckie’s words: “When we take the time to make sure a costume fits a dancer’s body properly, we’re showing them that their body deserves to be accommodated—that they don’t have to change themselves to belong. That their comfort and their boundaries actually matter.”